The Mad Hatter Rules of Civil Procedure

by Matthew Wadsworth

“If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is, because everything would be what it isn’t. And contrary wise, what is, it wouldn’t be. And what it wouldn’t be, it would. You see?”
– Lewis Carroll, Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland & Through the Looking-Glass.

Matthew WadsworthMy first court experience while cutting my teeth at Lundberg & Associates was the basketball equivalent of shooting free throws: processing evictions. The law was relatively simple, the rules of civil procedure at issue where clear, and everyone knew the rules, usually.

After departing on the adventure of starting my own firm, I found myself in the civil litigation world propounding the minutia of civil litigation both in federal court and state court discussing the nuances of expert witness testimony, privileges and dealing with insurance defense attorneys stretching the rules as far as they could to help their cause.

Now, because of the avalanche of domestic litigation finding its way to Arnold, Wadsworth & Coggins Attorneys, I find myself in what sometimes appears to be the bizarro world of civil procedure where to quote Captain Hector Barbossa in Disney’s “Pirates of the Caribbean,” “the code is more what you’d call guidelines than actual rules.” This article is written as a plea to our wonderful and brave court commissioners and the judges that oversee them to adopt uniform ground rules on certain topics, so practitioners can better serve the courts and counsel clients. There is ambiguity in the rules, which is the real culprit, and it needs to be resolved.

We are all familiar with the multitude of policies underwriting our civil litigation rules as well as the statutes governing our liberties. Our law school professors lectured us regarding interpreting the law and applying it in a way where all (or most) would reach similar results lest the naysayers cry foul play, bias or prejudice. Also, the uniformity of the law and its application serves the judicial economy allowing practitioners to counsel his or her clients in a way where out-of-court resolutions may more often be reached, so as to not bombard the courts with similar issues time and time again.

Naturally, because domestic law is so fact-intensive, there is an obvious rock-and-a-hard-place problem. Nevertheless, some rules I submit need to be uniform no matter the consequence.

First, the order to show cause. There is no uniformity amongst the judicial districts, judges within those judicial districts, or court commissioners within those judicial districts regarding the scope and boundaries of an order to show cause. Rule 101 states in pertinent part:

Limit on order to show cause. An application to the court for an order to show cause shall be made only for enforcement of an existing order or for sanctions for violating an existing order. An application for an order to show cause must be supported by affidavit or other evidence sufficient to show cause to believe a party has violated a court order.

Some courts allow the responding party to plead offsets having nothing to do with the applicant’s motion for the order to show cause, relevant or not, to offset the prospective damages turning the hearing into a he said/she said reality TV show where the parties fling all their dirty laundry in front of the court in hopes of plucking a heartstring. Others refuse to hear anything whatsoever from the responding party outside of the necessary standard of review i.e., knowledge of the order and willfully disobeying it. These courts often refuse to acknowledge even a counter-motion for an order to show cause without an actual order to show cause being signed, properly noticed and applied for.

When practicing under Rule 101, the plain language of the rule requires an application and a signed order to show cause to trigger the obligation to respond because an order to show cause is a contempt proceeding with the court not the opposing party. There is no procedure in the rules for hearing a counter order to show cause when filed under Rule 101(g) unless an actual order to show cause is signed by the court requiring the other party to respond. Some courts follow this procedure strictly.

Second: the objection hearing pursuant to Rule 108. When a party disagrees with a court commissioner the rules allow for an objection hearing and “upon request, to present testimony and other evidence on genuine issues of material fact” where the commissioner hearing “was held… on an order to show cause for the enforcement of a judgment.” Rule 108(d)(2). Further, if the order to show cause concerned domestic relations matters relevant to custody the party has the right to present testimony, but if the domestic relations matter concerned something other than custody the court may take evidence by testimony or proffers of testimony. Compare Rule 108(d)(3) (A) and Rule 108(d)(3)(B).

Frankly, there is zero uniformity in the judicial districts or amongst the judges and commissioners regarding the distinction between the two subparts of Rule 108(d)(3), or any part of Rule 108 for that matter. There is a due process right to cross-examine witnesses and conduct an evidentiary hearing when matters relate to custody. Rule 108(d)(3)(A). Further, it is common for different courts to allow other evidence to be considered at the objection hearing without it ever being offered before the commissioner in blatant violation of Rule 108(c) – even when no substantial change of circumstances is even argued much less overcome. Congruency amongst our courts regarding this procedural issue is advisable.

These are some of the examples of non-conformity, and there are others. Conformity amongst the courts, judges and commissioners on some of these ostensible minor procedural topics would increase judicial efficiency and allow practitioners to properly counsel clients. When the rules are not followed the court looks biased and prejudicial, and in an area of law where emotions are already heightened, it is the rules and uniformity in application of them which serves as the railing protecting clients from falling down the rabbit hole; nor are we Pirates of the Caribbean seeking to parley as if the rules were mere guidelines.

Please understand, this article is not written as a critique on liberal application of the rules of ethics and civility. The liberal granting of leeway on issues that don’t prejudice the client should always be followed, and a relaxation of some of the evidentiary rules in family law cases is certainly welcomed. This article is more of a plea for our courts to reach a uniform consensus in application of some of the ground rules that family law practitioners are struggling with every day due to the lack of conformity amongst our courts. It actually matters less what the consensus is, because we can adapt, but walking into court prepared for a full-fledged evidentiary hearing, which is what the rules call for, but ending up doing merely a proffer hearing, or preparing for a proffer hearing as called for by the rules and being told it is an evidentiary one is not good practice.

 


 
This article was originally published in the Attorney At Law Magazine for Greater Salt Lake City.
http://www.attorneyatlawmagazine.com/salt-lake-city/mad-hatters-rules-civil-procedure/

Testimonials

What They Say About Us

Google
Wyatt German profile picture
Wyatt German
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Deven Coggins and his paralegal Holly Ranger have done a great job helping me through my whole custody battle. I am a person that would rather get told the truth than just do whatever and go blindly. Deven, always gave his honest opinion and was not afraid to be straight forward. He had my best interest the whole time and fought very hard for me and always keeping our integrity intact. In that results as we stand I have full custody of my daughter. Highly recommend these two to anyone wanting a no Bs kind of lawyer.
Google
Madison Jones profile picture
Madison Jones
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I’m beyond thankful for the exceptional service I received from Brian Arnold. From day one, he showcased a deep understanding of family law and a clear commitment to my case. What truly stood out, however, was his remarkable ability to negotiate with the opposing counsel and secure an incredibly favorable resolution when it seemed like a tough situation. Throughout the process, Brian was thorough, transparent, and always kept me updated. He balanced assertiveness with empathy, ensuring that my needs were met without unnecessary stress or conflict. Thanks to Brian's negotiation expertise, we were able to avoid a prolonged legal battle and achieved a result that was far beyond what I had hoped for. I’m so relieved and pleased with the outcome. If you need a family law attorney who is not only skilled but also genuinely dedicated to achieving the best possible result for you, I can’t recommend Brian Arnold and his team enough. You’ll be in excellent hands.
Google
Jaycee Hill profile picture
Jaycee Hill
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I can’t thank Brian Arnold enough for the support and guidance during my divorce. From the beginning, him and his staff worked tirelessly to find a resolution that was fair and in my best interest, without the need to go to court. Their expertise in negotiation and mediation was evident, and they made what could have been a stressful and contentious process much smoother. If you’re looking for a divorce attorney who can handle things efficiently and effectively without the added stress of courtroom battles, I highly recommend Brian Arnold and the Arnold, Wadsworth & Coggins legal team.
Google
Owen Vannoy profile picture
Owen Vannoy
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I couldn’t have asked for a better team during a challenging time in my life. Arnold, Wadsworth & Coggins and its staff provided expert legal advice and compassionate support throughout the entire process. They were clear, responsive, and always had my best interests at heart. Their professionalism and empathy made a difficult situation much easier to navigate. Highly recommend them if you’re looking for top-notch legal representation.
Google
Alyssa Leigh profile picture
Alyssa Leigh
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I can’t thank Brian Arnold and his team enough for their support during my highly contested divorce. From the very beginning, they were professional, understanding, and extremely knowledgeable about every aspect of the case. The process was emotionally draining and complicated, but Brian and the team guided me every step of the way, making sure I understood my options and what to expect. Despite the challenges, they were able to negotiate a favorable settlement that protected my rights and helped me move forward with confidence. I always felt like they had my best interests at heart, and their attention to detail was impressive. If you’re facing a tough divorce, I highly recommend Brian Arnold and the Arnold, Wadsworth & Coggins team. They made a difficult time much easier to navigate, and I’m truly grateful for their expertise and support.
Google
Jordynn Schureman profile picture
Jordynn Schureman
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I’m very pleased with the service I received from Brian Arnold in handling my traffic citation. Brian quickly assessed my case, provided clear guidance, and worked efficiently to have the citation reduced, saving me both time and money. Brian and his staff kept me informed throughout the process and handled everything with professionalism. If you’re dealing with a traffic citation and want a hassle-free resolution, I highly recommend Brian Arnold.
Google
Jennifer McClellan profile picture
Jennifer McClellan
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I cannot recommend Arnold Wadsworth & Coggins enough. I was facing a serious and complex legal matter, and the team at Arnold Wadsworth & Coggins provided exceptional support every step of the way. Their expertise, professionalism, and clear communication helped me navigate a difficult situation with confidence. They were responsive, thorough, and truly dedicated to achieving the best outcome. Thanks to their hard work and strategic approach, I was able to reach a resolution that far exceeded my expectations. If you're dealing with a serious legal issue, Arnold Wadsworth & Coggins is the firm you want on your side. They combine expert legal knowledge with compassionate client care, making them stand out in their field.
Google
Jack Carver profile picture
Jack Carver
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Brian Arnold helped me with my criminal case. He got me a plea in abeyance and the charge expunged so it's no longer on my record. Brian is an amazing attorney and I definitely recommend working with him.

Utah Divorce Attorneys

Compassionate & Aggressive Representation for Your Family Law Needs

Family Law & Divorce

When it comes to family law and divorce matters, our lawyers take into account how difficult your situation may be right now. As Utah divorce attorneys, we fight aggressively for your rights in litigation, but we will always treat you with compassion and sensitivity — in the same way we would treat our own family members. In fact, the support we provide to our clients is so heartfelt that most remain in contact with us for years after their case has been favorably resolved.

Voted as a Top Utah Family Law Attorney

Don't Hesitate to Contact the Utah Divorce Lawyers

If you are seeking legal help on divorce, divorce modification, child support, or child custody, don’t delay in contacting us. The sooner you call us, the sooner you can get things resolved for you and your kids. In some cases, you may only have a limited amount of time to act before it’s too late to defend yourself or get the resolution you want. We know how painful things are right now, and we want to resolve your issues as quickly as possible so you can rebuild your life and the precious bonds you have with your family.

Meet Our Experts

Qualified Attorneys

Sterling Arnold

Attorney

Brian E. Arnold

Partner & Attorney

Matt Wadsworth

Partner & Attorney

Deven J. Coggins

Partner & Attorney

Lauren Schultz

Associate

Cobie Spevak

Attorney

Ready to Protect Your Rights? Contact Us Today!

Get trusted legal representation for your case. Schedule a consultation now.